| *D.B. Connett: 1916 - 1918 |
*Walter Muench: 1969 - 1970 |
| *Charles Lade: 1919-1919 |
Rocco Cifrese: 1971 - 1972 |
| *Clarence Paugh: 1920 - 1923 |
*Nicholas Smarg: 1973 - 1974 |
| *James McGrath: 1924-1924 |
Carl Glaab: 1975 - 1976 |
| *Lloyd Hopper: 1925 - 1927 |
Richard Mack: 1977 - 1978 |
| *J.J. Burling: 1928 - 1928 |
Jules Grosjean: 1979 - 1980 |
| *Clarence Paugh: 1929 - 1929 |
Brian Phelan: 1981 - 1982 |
| *Durward Hulbert: 1930 - 1931 |
Jeffrey Betz: 1983 - 1984 |
| *Lloyd Hopper: 1932 - 1933 |
Evan Thomas: 1985 - 1986 |
| *Leslie Conklin: 1934 - 1937 |
George E McKinnell: 1987 - 1988 |
| *Daniel Dailey: 1938 - 1939 |
Bruce Schmeal: 1989 - 1990 |
| *Charles Prudden: 1940
-1941 |
Denis Menton: 1991 - 1992 |
| *Daniel Dailey: 1942 - 1945 |
Evan Thomas: 1993 - 1994 |
| *Frank Flemming: 1947-1947 |
Brian Phelan: 1995 - 1995 |
| *Elliott Domans: 1948 - 1949 |
James Long: 1996 - 1997 |
| *Frank Flemming: 1950 - 1950 |
Christopher Steinberg: 1998 - 1998 |
| *Raymond Woodhull: 1951 - 1952 |
James Long: 1999 - 1999 |
| *Peter Burnett: 1953 - 1954 |
Robert Pierson: 2000 - 2001 |
| *Roland Potts: 1955 - 1956 |
John (Jack) Alderton: 2002 - 2003 |
| *Russell Apgar Jr.: 1957 - 1958 |
Jeffrey Thornberry: 2004 - 2004 |
| *John Stockton: 1959 - 1960 |
Samuel Tolley: 2005 - 2006 |
| *George McKinnell: 1961 - 1962 |
Evan Thomas: 2007 - 2008 |
| *Samuel Tufts: 1963 - 1964 |
Ross Johnson: 2009 - 2010 |
|
| *Ernest Maw: 1965 - 1966 |
|
| *William Buchwald: 1967 - 1968 |
|